Defect: a rating on the wrong substrate
ES-1 specimens use the same materials, details and anchoring devices as a real building, so a rating belongs to the assembly that was tested.
AFS's wind screening tool says tested capacity never carries over to a different substrate; Drexel's Snap Coping-Max print approval shows stainless woodscrews.
So a wood-screw rating is no evidence for a steel stud or masonry parapet: ask the manufacturer.
Sources
- ANSI/SPRI/FM 4435/ES-1-2022 Test Standard for Edge Systems Used with Low Slope Roofing Systems (approved November 21, 2022) - SPRI
- AFS wind uplift and edge screening (Design Center): the checklist printed with every result, and Drexel's published ratings shown beside the demand - Architectural Flashing Supply
- Drexel Metals ES-1 technical data sheets, print approvals, installation guides and guide specifications for the systems AFS fabricates - Drexel Metals
